Sub-Prime Lending In An Over Heating Market Is Back. How Worried Should We Be?

It is starting to look a bit familiar. Is the housing bubble heading for a 2008-style crash?

By Jeff Vasishta October 27, 2016
Photo courtesy of Naytev Insights

Like a black and white horror movie villain, sub-prime lending has stepped in from the shadows and is about to scare the b’jesus out of us all. The fact that low or no down payment deals are once again on the table is more than a little disconcerting. In the most overheated real estate market since the crash of ’08, banks and economists are uttering that dreaded word that rhymes with trouble and begins with a B.

Related: Real Estate 2016: Boom or Bubble?

Lenders such as Quicken Loans and Caliber Funding are fueling the new frenzy, originating 63 percent of the $10 trillion currently owed on one to four family residences. Known as non-banks, or “shadow banks,” like something out of James Bond film, they have now overtaken commercial banks “to grab a record slice” of government-guaranteed mortgages, Attom Data Solutions reported in its housing report.

Photo courtesy of Naytev Insights

So how does a shadow bank differ from a conventional bank like Chase or Bank Of America? Usually they source their funds from Wall St. hedge funds, private lenders or banks themselves. They make loans then sell these mortgages to Fannie Mae and Freddie Mac and other buyers, so they can repay their loans and start the process over again. Freddie and Fanny then package these loans into mortgage-backed securities, and guarantee them to make investors whole if the mortgages default. Sound familiar?

While many features of the last housing crash are indeed present today—like an overheated market and subprime and low or no down payments through shadow banks and government agencies—many are not. For instance, during the last housing crash a credit score of 620 or more was generally required, even with low down payment. Now the lowest score is considerably more. Paper work and underwriting today is significantly more extensive.

Thirdly, new home construction was on fire in 08. There were always more homes to sell so brokers, agents and appraisers kept increasing prices in an unchecked, ever upward spiral. Certainly in some parts of the country new construction is dizzying and in New York it’s hitting record numbers again but it’s not at the staggering rate in Las Vegas and Florida that it was 2008. Also New York buyers are wealthy, often foreign and often all cash. Many of the developers like Miami condo king Jorge Perez have made it a point for buyers to put a 50 percent down payment thus limiting the risk of over leveraging—which was a major factor for the last bubble. With that in mind, lenders, even shadow banks, generally won’t lend to owners of multiple properties which definitely wasn’t the case in ’08. And as for HELOC’s on second homes or investment properties and those crazy Option ARM payment plans, good luck asking for those this time around. We all remember what happened to Countrywide and Washington Mutual.

Bottom line it’s OK to be afraid. But not too afraid.

Jeff Vasishta



Jeff is a writer, husband and father but not necessarily in that order. As a music journalist he counts Prince, Beyonce and Quincy Jones amongst those he’s interviewed. He's also owned and flipped homes in Brooklyn, NJ, CT and PA.

    Do you know how the so-called “affordable” real estate in New York is getting less affordable by the day whereas the city’s luxury market is softening? #luxury #condo
    One of the most iconic buildings in Boston has officially been sold and hopefully, the iconic station will be upgraded. #Boston #SouthStation
    This week, three of the apartments in the starchitect-designed West Chelsea condo have hit the rental market. #zahahadid #chelsea
The Most Walkable City In The United States Is NYC
It’s no surprise that New York City is the most walkable city in the United States. Everything in the Big Apple makes it the ideal…
10 Booming Cities In The United States Where Homes Are Still Affordable
In most of the United States, buying a house is getting more and more pricey.  The main factor behind this scenario can be explained or…
New Rentals At Zaha Hadid’s West Chelsea Condo Hit The Market
Living NYC’s newly developed condo buildings is a privilege reserved strictly for the well-heeled. This is especially true when the condo tower in question has…
Can We Go Higher? NYC’s Costliest Condos Are Getting Even More Expensive
Do you know how the so-called “affordable” real estate in New York is getting less affordable by the day whereas the city’s luxury market is…
The Iconic Plaza Hotel In New York City Is Looking For Buyers
One of New York City’s most iconic properties could be having new owners very soon. The Indian business conglomerate, Sahara Group, has hired a broker…
A New 20,000-Square-Foot Megamansion Might Be Coming To Manhattan’s Greenwich Village
For the filthy rich living in the heart of Manhattan, condos in glassy towers seem to be the most common option these days. Lavish pads…
New Retail Strip Is Coming To Astoria Area With A Troubled Past
It seems like a bad coincidence, but the Dutch Kill neighborhood, located in otherwise prosperous Astoria, did manage to live up to its, ahem, colorful…
UN New York Hotel To Rebrand As Millennium Hilton New York One UN Plaza
The United Nations Plaza complex is an iconic landmark in Manhattan. It is a key property located across from the United Nations Headquarters that is…