Five Pros And Cons Of Owning A Landmarked Building In NYC

Owning a townhouse on a landmarked block is quite the status symbol in NYC. But is it all it’s cracked up to be?

By Jeff Vasishta December 15, 2016

It all started in 1963 with the much-protested demolition of New York’s old Pennsylvania Station. Two years later, NYC’s Landmarks Law was created to protect historic sites and buildings from being demolished—or altered beyond all recognition. Recent gentrification has heightened the focus on the subject of landmarking as neighborhood associations fight to keep their properties away from the clutches of developers.

In a city filled with historic buildings, landmarking has proved pivotal in preserving New York’s character, particularly in areas like brownstone Brooklyn. In fact, Brooklyn Heights was the first historic district to be designated Landmark status in 1965. Now, large swathes of the city have been landmarked, with others on the calendar. Although there are many types of landmarked and historic buildings in NYC, for simplicity’s sake we’ll keep this article focused on residential (think—brownstone) buildings. If you suddenly find your property is about to join the coveted ranks of the NYC’s historic districts, what’s in it for you, if anything?

RelatedMidtown’s Former Citicorp Center Makes The Cut As NYC’s Youngest Landmark


The character of neighborhoods is maintained

Architecturally speaking, a mismatched neighborhood can be an eyesore. A brownstone next to a cheap and cheerful stucco-ed Home Depot special, next to an apartment building. There’s a reason why houses on all brownstone blocks cost more money. It’s because developers haven’t got in there and razed rather than renovated.

Property values are higher

As mentioned above, an historic district is one of the first things a broker will mention in a sales pitch, for a good reason. They’re more coveted. There’s a security in knowing that legally, your street will likely remain the way it has been for the last 100 years for.

RelatedHistoric L.A. Landmark To Be Preserved As Affordable Housing

Neighborhoods get stabilized

A landmarked neighborhood tends to attract homeowners rather than investors. Investors rent to tenants, who are liable to be more transient, whereas homeowners take pride in maintaining and looking after their property. Also, landmarked blocks, particularly brownstones, have recently started reverting back to single family homes, which means children are being raised in them, and a neighborhood vibe will once again flourish.

The city will help you restore or update your historic home

Low interest loans are available for certain rehab projects in historic neighborhoods. Organizations such as Neighborhood Housing Services of New York City will help you restore and maintain your property so long as your rehab projects are cosmetic or plumbing and electricity related—as opposed to structural. The Landmark Preservation Commission’s Historic Preservation Grant Program provides funding between $10,000 and $20,000 for income-eligible owners of landmarked properties for proposed repair work or alterations. The New York Landmarks Conservancy is another organization that provides financial assistance for renovation of historic properties.

Tax credits are available

Significant tax credits are available if you are restoring your historic home such as a New York State Homeowner Tax Credit. If you’re renovating an income-generating property, you can get a 20 percent tax credit—as long as your renovation meets these criteria.



Exterior renovations must fall within specific guidelines

There’s a price to pay for keeping your neighborhood historic looking. Broadly speaking, if you own a brownstone, you have to keep your house looking as if a horse and carriage just passed down your gas-lit street. That means—no replacing wooden window frames with aluminum ones, no deciding to do away with your brownstone stoop in favor of something maintenance friendly, and no paving over your front garden and knocking down your exterior wall to make a driveway to absolve yourself of alternate side of the street parking rules.

No changes to occupancy permits for investors

If you’ve purchased a single-family brownstone with the intent of chopping it up into rental units, think again. The city will not approve of you altering the original layout and Certificate of Occupancy of a property to turn a profit. If, however, your house had already been a multi-unit before it was designated a landmarked building, you may continue to use it as such.

Gentrification will increase

If you’ve lived in the black sections of Brooklyn, such as Bed-Stuy and Crown Heights, for many years and loved the neighborhood feel, then here is bad news. Once your block becomes landmarked, it could encourage gentrification rather than hinder it. A landmarked block carries with it a certain prestige—and this, naturally, is the quality that new buyers are naturally drawn to. Let’s face it—much of the old neighborhood is changing, but adding an extra $250-$500K to the price of a house may force your long standing neighbors to sell sooner rather than later.

Sometimes old is just old

In discussing a proposal for another historic district in Bed-Stuy, the New York Times quoted Michael Slattery, the senior vice president for research at the Real Estate Board of New York, an organization that has been vocal in identifying potential downsides of historic designation. It cited many structures in the proposed district that it considers decidedly mediocre:

“Looking at these inferior structures we ask ourselves: Are these buildings or the collection of buildings so special, so distinctive, that we want to preserve them forever?”

Older & fixed-income residents won’t be able to afford renovations

It can be a pain having someone tell you what you can and can’t do with your property, especially when you’ve owned it for 50+ years. However, older residents with limited resources will be the first ones to feel the brunt when a property gets a historic designation. The renovations may just be beyond them and they may be the first to go. Thus, the very fabric that made a community what it was could start to erode.

Jeff Vasishta



Jeff is a writer, husband and father but not necessarily in that order. As a music journalist he counts Prince, Beyonce and Quincy Jones amongst those he’s interviewed. He's also owned and flipped homes in Brooklyn, NJ, CT and PA.

    Stefano Boeri, the architect mastermind behind the famous plant-covered skyscrapers, is now designing Forest Cities in Liuzhou, China. #ForestCity #China
    Auction is the second scheduled in a month for a One57 unit and it could set a NYC foreclosure record. #BillionairesRow #Foreclosures
    Once a couch-surfing website, Airbnb moves on to luxury properties, further disrupting hospitality industry. #Airbnb #Luxury
Four Countries To Retire In With $200K In Savings—And How Much Real Estate Costs There
Ever dreamed of retiring abroad? You know, affordable healthcare, better climate, more positive news—becoming an expat seems like an enticing option, especially one you no…
While Other Real Estate Platforms Start Charging Agents $3-Per-Day Exposure Fee, Agorafy Remains Accessible To All
Real Estate searching platform are always finding news ways to diversify their revenues models. Case in point—on Tuesday July 18, Streeteasy, one of New York…
Is Real Estate Crowdfunding The Fix That Urban Housing In America Really Needs?
Saving money for a down payment? One can only hope. Most millennial in their twenties or thirties are mortified that they might never be able…
Brooklyn And Queens’ Real Estate Sub-Markets Continue Their Ascent To The New Heights
So, the sales prices in Brooklyn and Queens hit record highs. Again. Just like they did in December 2016 and at the end of this…
The Economy Of Car Services And Delivery Apps Might Be Making NYC Less Eco-Friendly
Living in an eco-friendly neighborhood is a good thing. And, as it always the case with the good things, it also costs more. High rents…
Building Communities: What The U.S. Developers Should Learn From Soho China
As our world emerges into the new period of globalization and technology, some of the most important by-products of this process are buildings that have…
Five Reasons Why All Entrepreneurs Must Keep Their Eyes On China
It is hard to overestimate the importance of Chinese influence on the modern global economy. Carving out a place in Chinese market and winning over…
Airbnb Up Their Game With A New Luxury Tier Featuring Mansions And Villas
Airbnb is about to seriously up their game. First, the company started testing a new service called Select in an attempt to push accommodation listings…