Top Five Homes To Buy In NYC’s Most Unaffordable Borough

If you live in Brooklyn, chances are, your rent already costs you an arm and leg—so you might as well buy your own place.

By Team Agorafy December 2, 2016
Brooklyn Bridge. Photo courtesy of Jonathan Pease

So you no longer can afford to rent in Brooklyn? Well, maybe you should just buy your own place then. We know, we probably sound like one of your parents, but hear us out. Recently, Agorafy reported on the curious study, completed by StreetEasy. According to their calculations,, in certain NYC neighborhoods—lots of which are in Brooklyn— you will actually be better off buying homes, not renting them.

Sounds odd, but the numbers don’t lie—after a certain tipping point (a term used by StreetEasy analysts,) all this money you spend on rent pretty much goes down the drain.

RelatedTop Five Office Spaces For Sublease In Prime Manhattan Locations

Here at Agorafy we went through the listings on our platform and cherry picked some apartments for sale in those Brooklyn neighborhoods where buying makes the most sense. Now, instead of renting a glorified closet in what has officially been dubbed the most unaffordable borough, you can own one—how cool is that?


Windsor Terrace 651 Vanderbilt Street

1 BR | 1 BA     Price: $395,000

This co-op, located just a stone’s throw from Prospect Park, is “partially renovated”—whatever that means. And frankly, we don’t care: in this area, real estate might soon cost like those Midtown high-end condos, so grab it while you still can.

651 vanderbilt street


Fort Greene 115 Ashland Place

1 BR | 1 BA     Price: $480,000

We know we promised you a glorified closet, but this co-op is actually quite spacious, with an oversized bedroom and a bike storage.



Prospect Heights / 34 Plaza Street

1 BR | 1 BA     $725,000

Another spacious gem on Grand Army Plaza. The listing boasts three large closets. By NYC standards, it’s a four-bedroom abode, folks.


Related: Top Five Apartments For Rent Next To Soon-To-Open Second Avenue Train

Sunset Park / 227 West 34th Street

1 BR | 1 BA     $560,000 

This beautifully-renovated apartment boasts white oak floors and immaculate kitchen set-up. Renting in Sunset Park isn’t that expensive—but that’s about to change soon, with all these start-up companies moving to local industrial buildings. Buy this gem—or the tech hipsters will.



Brownsville 487 Powell Street

3 BR | 1.5 BA     Price: $429,000

Brownsville might not be as glamorous and hip as the other neighborhoods we have picked. And that’s why, if you decide to invest your money here, you are getting the whole single-family house—renovated and with a finished basement.

487 Powell Street

Team Agorafy



Our mission is to be the most accurate resource for commercial listings, residential listings, and property information, allowing users to make highly-informed decisions based on current market data.

    Do you know how the so-called “affordable” real estate in New York is getting less affordable by the day whereas the city’s luxury market is softening? #luxury #condo
    One of the most iconic buildings in Boston has officially been sold and hopefully, the iconic station will be upgraded. #Boston #SouthStation
    This week, three of the apartments in the starchitect-designed West Chelsea condo have hit the rental market. #zahahadid #chelsea
The Most Walkable City In The United States Is NYC
It’s no surprise that New York City is the most walkable city in the United States. Everything in the Big Apple makes it the ideal…
10 Booming Cities In The United States Where Homes Are Still Affordable
In most of the United States, buying a house is getting more and more pricey.  The main factor behind this scenario can be explained or…
New Rentals At Zaha Hadid’s West Chelsea Condo Hit The Market
Living NYC’s newly developed condo buildings is a privilege reserved strictly for the well-heeled. This is especially true when the condo tower in question has…
Can We Go Higher? NYC’s Costliest Condos Are Getting Even More Expensive
Do you know how the so-called “affordable” real estate in New York is getting less affordable by the day whereas the city’s luxury market is…
The Iconic Plaza Hotel In New York City Is Looking For Buyers
One of New York City’s most iconic properties could be having new owners very soon. The Indian business conglomerate, Sahara Group, has hired a broker…
A New 20,000-Square-Foot Megamansion Might Be Coming To Manhattan’s Greenwich Village
For the filthy rich living in the heart of Manhattan, condos in glassy towers seem to be the most common option these days. Lavish pads…
New Retail Strip Is Coming To Astoria Area With A Troubled Past
It seems like a bad coincidence, but the Dutch Kill neighborhood, located in otherwise prosperous Astoria, did manage to live up to its, ahem, colorful…
UN New York Hotel To Rebrand As Millennium Hilton New York One UN Plaza
The United Nations Plaza complex is an iconic landmark in Manhattan. It is a key property located across from the United Nations Headquarters that is…